Quick Columbia TN MLS Search

Browse All Columbia TN Between $400K - $500K Properties for Sale

$464,900
4 Beds 3 Baths 3223057 MLS ACTIVE Status 0.27 Acres 38401 Zip Code
Move-In Ready and Tons of Upgrades. This is the one buyers have been waiting for. This stunning 4-bedroom home features the primary suite on the MAIN level and a flexible layout designed for both comfort and functionality. With a 4-car garage setup / brand-new 24x24 workshop / man cave with over 9' ceilings, this property offers space that is incredibly hard to find. Fenced in yard, No backyard neighbors, All stainless steel appliances including washer and dryer stay. The kitchen is built to impress with granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, stained cabinetry, a large island, abundant counter space, and a pantry. The oversized Bonus Room easily functions as a 4th bedroom, playroom, office, guest suite or teen retreat. Throughout the home you’ll find spacious rooms, extra storage, and a large walk-in laundry room with it's own closet on the main level conveniently located near the primary suite. Recent upgrades include luxury carpeting with premium memory-foam padding, fresh paint throughout (walls, trim, and doors), new rear siding, a freshly re-stained deck, reseeded lawn, updated landscaping and grading, rounded handrails, and a pocket door added to the primary bath. The garage features upgraded epoxy floors and painted finished walls. The brand-new 24 x 24 detached shop is a standout feature. Perfect for a workshop, hobby space, or ultimate man cave. Plus additional garage space for two more vehicles, creating a true 4-car garage setup. Step outside to a fenced backyard that backs directly to a farm with no rear neighbors, offering rare privacy and peaceful open views. Additional highlights include walk-in attic storage, an ADT security system already in place that Buyers can take over and a deluxe storm door (valued at $1100) that everyone wishes they had. Homes with this much space, privacy and upgrades rarely come available. This is a must-have property. Make this house your next home.

1901 Sheffield Ln, Columbia

$471,830
4 Beds 3 Baths 3210913 MLS UNDER CONTRACT - NOT SHOWING Status 0.164 Acres 38401 Zip Code
PRESALE. The Harrison plan in Hillcrest Village with an open layout perfect for entertaining and everyday living is a stunning quick move-in opportunity—ready for you to settle in without the wait! High-end finishes elevate this home to feel truly luxurious: • Gorgeous granite countertops in the kitchen • Tile shower in the primary bath • Relaxing soaking tub • Upgraded appliance package • Covered deck for seamless outdoor enjoyment • Cozy fireplace with shiplap surround • Hardwood stairs adding timeless elegance Imagine waking up to rolling hills, fresh air, and a neighborhood designed for real living—not just existing. That’s Hillcrest Village in Columbia, TN—M/I Homes’ newest master-planned community that’s turning heads for all the right reasons. Prime Location Without the Big-City Hassle Just minutes from historic Downtown Columbia’s charming shops, restaurants, farmers market, and arts scene. Brand-New Homes Built Smarter and Amenities That Make Every Day Better This isn’t your standard subdivision. Hillcrest Village stands out with family- and pet-friendly perks like playgrounds, a picnic area, dedicated dog park, community garden, and a scenic overlook with stunning views. The Harrison delivers an inviting open-concept main level with a spacious kitchen flowing into the dining and family room—ideal for gatherings. Current incentives make it even easier to call this home yours: Lock in a low 4.875% 30-year fixed rate and $10,000 toward closing costs when using M/I Financial. (Offers are subject to change—contact us for full details.) Don’t wait—schedule your visit today and step into this move-in-ready gem at Hillcrest Village! If you’re ready for a home that feels modern, connected, and welcoming—complete with high-end touches and unbeatable incentives.Hillcrest Village is calling your name.

3003 Sharpstone Court, Columbia

$487,905
5 Beds 3 Baths 3205278 MLS UNDER CONTRACT - NOT SHOWING Status 38401 Zip Code
Welcome to the brand-new Highlands of Carter's Station community! Conveniently located between Spring Hill and the charming downtown square of Columbia, Highlands of Carter's Station offers the best of small town living within close proximity of Nashville. Let me introduce you to this brand-new 5 Bed / 3 Bath “Whimbrel” home! Inside you’ll find a thoughtfully designed layout featuring a spacious Great Room, ideal for family gatherings. The Kitchen seamlessly flows into the dining area, making entertaining a breeze. A versatile Flex Space on the main floor allows for a home office or formal Dining Room. Upstairs, a Loft provides additional living space, perfect for a media room or play area. Each of the 5 Bedrooms includes a walk-in closet, ensuring ample storage. The Owner’s Bathroom includes tile flooring, dual sinks with quartz countertops, and an Large Walk in Tiled shower. Step outside to enjoy your private rear patio, ideal for year-round outdoor relaxation. With contemporary finishes, energy-efficient features and a prime location, this home is a must-see! The Highlands of Carter's Station community will also feature a pool and cabana, located just down the street from this home. Close in proximity to Spring Hill schools, shopping, dining and I-65, Highlands of Carter's Station allows you to enjoy the convenience of city living while maintaining a peaceful neighborhood ambiance.

3429 Fellowship Road, Columbia

$492,030
4 Beds 3 Baths 3175506 MLS UNDER CONTRACT - NOT SHOWING Status 0.241 Acres 38401 Zip Code
☀️🔥 Summer is heating up in Hillcrest Village, and this quick move-in ready Columbus plan is shining with luxury and ready for your best season yet! Picture golden Tennessee sunshine pouring through the windows as you step into this fresh, move-in-ready retreat. Warm breezes invite you to the open gourmet kitchen where sunlight dances on gorgeous quartz countertops and upgraded appliances gleam—perfect for al fresco feasts and backyard barbecues. The main level flows effortlessly to a cozy shiplap-wrapped fireplace, ideal for magical mild summer evenings and relaxed gatherings. A dedicated study offers the perfect quiet space for work or hobbies, while the primary suite downstairs provides a peaceful escape with a spa-inspired bath featuring a sleek tile shower, deep soaking tub, and generous walk-in closet. Hardwood stairs add timeless warmth leading upstairs to the versatile rec room—your go-to spot for summer movie nights, game days, or family fun. The covered deck/patio becomes your all-season outdoor oasis for morning coffee, sunset dinners, or chilling under the stars. This thoughtfully designed home delivers effortless flow: open kitchen-family room, flex spaces, smart layout, and plenty of room to grow Location perfection just minutes from historic Downtown Columbia’s charming shops, farm-fresh markets, cozy eateries, and vibrant arts scene. Enjoy easy Nashville access, small-town charm without the traffic, plus community perks like playgrounds, dog park, gardens, picnic areas, and scenic overlooks! Hillcrest Village is family- and pet-friendly with panoramic views and luxury finishes throughout. Premium upgrades included: quartz counters, primary tile shower & soaking tub, upgraded appliances, covered deck/patio, shiplap fireplace, and hardwood stairs. Don't miss your chance to take advantage of limited-time Dream Big incentives!

2965 Sharpstone Dr, Columbia

$414,900
4 Beds 3 Baths 3171614 MLS ACTIVE Status 0.41000000000000003 Acres 38401 Zip Code
Under contract with a 48-hour right of first refusal. Property remains active and showings are encouraged. BACK ON THE MARKET — AND BETTER THAN BEFORE! $15,000 Seller Concession + APPRAISED ABOVE LIST PRICE! 1% lender credit available through the preferred lender for qualified buyers. This beautifully renovated 4-bedroom, 3-bath home offers a fresh, modern feel with quality updates throughout. The open floor plan creates an inviting space for everyday living and entertaining, while the kitchen features marble countertops, brand-new stainless steel appliances, and generous cabinet space. The spacious primary suite includes a beautifully finished private bath, with two additional renovated bathrooms offering stylish floor-to-ceiling marble finishes. Extensive improvements include updated plumbing, electrical, HVAC, water heater, insulation, flooring, cabinetry, fixtures, and more—providing peace of mind long after closing. Enjoy a fenced backyard, oversized concrete driveway, and a location just minutes from Downtown Columbia, shopping, dining, parks, and more. Recently under contract and back on the market through no fault of the home. Appraised ABOVE the current list price, with $15,000 available toward closing costs, prepaid expenses, or an interest rate buy-down. Brand-new kitchen appliances are included and come with the manufacturer’s factory warranty for the buyer to activate after closing. The maximum seller contribution is $15,000 total, including any buyer closing costs, concessions, and buyer-agent compensation.

206 Osage Trl, Columbia

$486,399
4 Beds 3 Baths 3138059 MLS UNDER CONTRACT - NOT SHOWING Status 0.164 Acres 38401 Zip Code
The Harrison plan in Hillcrest Village with an open layout perfect for entertaining and everyday living is a stunning quick move-in opportunity—ready for you to settle in without the wait! High-end finishes elevate this home to feel truly luxurious: • Crown molding on the main level • Gorgeous quartz countertops in the kitchen • Tile shower in the primary bath • Relaxing soaking tub • Upgraded appliance package • Covered deck for seamless outdoor enjoyment • Cozy fireplace with shiplap surround • Hardwood stairs adding timeless elegance Imagine waking up to rolling hills, fresh air, and a neighborhood designed for real living—not just existing. That’s Hillcrest Village in Columbia, TN—M/I Homes’ newest master-planned community that’s turning heads for all the right reasons. Prime Location Without the Big-City Hassle Just minutes from historic Downtown Columbia’s charming shops, restaurants, farmers market, and arts scene. Brand-New Homes Built Smarter and Amenities That Make Every Day Better This isn’t your standard subdivision. Hillcrest Village stands out with family- and pet-friendly perks like playgrounds, a picnic area, dedicated dog park, community garden, and a scenic overlook with stunning views. The Harrison delivers an inviting open-concept main level with a spacious kitchen flowing into the dining and family room—ideal for gatherings. Current incentives make it even easier to call this home yours: Lock in a low 4.875% 30-year fixed rate and $10,000 toward closing costs when using M/I Financial. (Offers are subject to change—contact us for full details.) Don’t wait—schedule your visit today and step into this move-in-ready gem at Hillcrest Village! If you’re ready for a home that feels modern, connected, and welcoming—complete with high-end touches and unbeatable incentives.Hillcrest Village is calling your name.

3143 Rolling Brook Drive, Columbia

Start Your Search
board logo

Information Is Believed To Be Accurate But Not Guaranteed. Some or all listings may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting these featured properties. Copyright 2026 MTRMLS, Inc. RealTracs Solutions.

Between $400K - $500K Columbia Real Estate

Our website features the best real estate search for between $400k - $500k properties available in Columbia and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire. 

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood! 

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Contact us today to find out how we can be of assistance to you!